Topics: Invoice Auditing, Invoice Management
As companies look to reduce costs and improve controls, many are evaluating outsourced invoice audit and payment providers. While technology, analytics, and cost savings often receive the most attention during the vendor selection process, organizations should also understand the legal, regulatory, and financial framework supporting the movement of funds.
Not all providers operate under the same regulatory structure. Understanding how a provider facilitates payments, manages compliance obligations, handles vendor relationships, and accesses payment networks can help organizations evaluate and make more informed outsourcing decisions.
What Compliance Risks Should Companies Evaluate Before Outsourcing Accounts Payable?
Outsourcing accounts payable can streamline operations, but it also places a third party in the flow of your funds, vendor relationships, and sensitive data. Ask the following key compliance questions before outsourcing to a third party.
1. Does the provider operate within the appropriate regulatory framework?
The first and most important question is whether the provider operates within the applicable U.S. legal and regulatory framework for outsourced business-to-business accounts payable services.
If the provider receives your funds and subsequently facilitates payments to your vendors, then the U.S. Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) generally recognizes three legally permissible structures:
-
The provider should be appropriately licensed or registered, such as a bank or licensed third-party processor.
-
The provider acts as a delegate of a licensed entity.
-
The provider's services and operating model satisfy applicable federal and state exemptions.
Organizations should remember FinCEN registration and state licensing requirements considerations. Federal law expressly preserves state oversight, making it important to understand how a provider satisfies both federal and state obligations.
2. If thee provider is not licensed, how are vendor payments facilitated?
If your provider is not a regulated financial institution or licensed money transmission provider, it is important to understand how vendor payments are legally structured.
One common approach is for the provider to establish direct contractual relationships with vendors. In certain circumstances, this structure may support exemptions from specific licensing requirements by transferring payment liability from the customer to the service provider once funds have been received.
As a result, organizations should ask:
-
Is the provider licensed?
-
Does the provider maintain direct contracts with vendors?
-
If not, what legal framework supports compliance in FinCEN and applicable state requirements?
Understanding these distinctions can help reduce regulatory and operational risk.
3. How does the provider handle contracts, confidentiality, and audit data?
Effective invoice audit programs require access to more than invoices alone. Providers frequently need access to contracts, pricing schedules, rate agreements, and supporting documentation to validate billing accuracy.
Many vendor agreements include confidentiality clauses, non-disclosure obligations, and restrictions on sharing information with third parties. In some instances, both customer and vendor approval may be required before information can be shared externally.
Organizations should verify that their provider understands and complies with these contractual obligations. Failure to do so can expose the customer to unnecessary legal and financial risk.
This issue is especially relevant in parcel audit environments where agreements with major carriers such as FedEx, UPS, and DHL often contain highly specific contractual requirements.
4. How does the provider access the payment system?
Organizations should also understand the relationship between their provider and the financial institution that ultimately facilitates access to payment networks and settlement systems, including the payment security measures supporting those transactions. As financial technology continues to evolve, payment providers may utilize a variety of models, ranging from traditional banking relationships to newer technologies involving tokenized deposits and other digital payment structures.
Examples of controls and requirements frequently associated with regulated financial institutions include:
-
Anti-money laundering (AML) programs
-
Suspicious activity report (SAR) capabilities
-
Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) compliance programs
-
State reporting and licensing requirements
-
ACH governance and contractual responsibilities
-
UCC Article 4A risk allocation requirements
Why Does Working with a Regulated Financial Institution Matter?
The regulatory framework supporting a payment provider can have significant implications for risk management, operational controls, reporting capabilities, and accountability. Many organizations focus primarily on technology features and pricing, but understanding how funds move through the payment process is equally important.
A regulated financial institution, such as Cass Commercial Bank, may offer established compliance programs, formal oversight structures, payment expertise, and operational safeguards that support secure and compliant transaction processing. These considerations should be evaluated alongside functionality, service levels, and cost savings during the vendor selection process.
Putting Risk into Perspective
Organizations evaluating outsourced invoice audit and payment providers should look beyond software functionality and cost reduction opportunities. Understanding the regulatory, contractual, and operational framework behind the movement of funds is a critical component of the vendor selection process.
By asking the right questions regarding licensing, contractual relationships, compliance controls, data governance, and payment execution, organizations can make more informed decisions and reduce third-party risk.
Ultimately, selecting a qualified provider with the appropriate expertise, controls, and regulatory framework can help improve operational efficiency while strengthening financial oversight and accountability.